You’ve heard the buzzword and want to know what is disruptive innovation. It is a process where a smaller company with fewer resources successfully challenges established incumbents. Here is how it works and what it isn’t.
If you are new to the wider topic, start with what is innovation, then come back here for the disruptive kind.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Concept first introduced | 1995 Harvard Business Review paper by Clayton Christensen and Joseph Bower |
| Popularizing book | The Innovator’s Dilemma, 1997 |
| Backlash article | 2014 New Yorker article by Jill Lepore |
| Time before the concept was revisited | 20 years |
| Revisiting paper | “What is Disruptive Innovation?” in HBR’s December issue |
These details come from a blog post by Irving Wladawsky-Berger on the concept’s first 20 years. Figures and framings can change, so check the source before you rely on them.
Where the idea comes from
The concept of disruptive innovation was first introduced by Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen in a 1995 Harvard Business Review paper co-written with Joseph Bower. It was then elaborated and popularized in Christensen’s 1997 bestseller The Innovator’s Dilemma, according to Wladawsky-Berger’s account.
Few business concepts have been as long and widely used. That popularity came with a cost: the idea became a trendy, overused buzzword, stretched and applied beyond its intended meaning.
A rather strong backlash followed in a 2014 New Yorker article by Harvard history professor Jill Lepore. Then, 20 years after the introduction, Christensen revisited his own concept in a paper titled What is Disruptive Innovation?, co-written with Michael Raynor and Rory McDonald and published in HBR’s December issue (source).
What does disruption actually mean?
The revisiting paper defines disruption as a process whereby a smaller company with fewer resources is able to successfully challenge established incumbent businesses. The key word is “process”: disruption unfolds over time rather than happening at launch.
The authors’ stated aim was to define what disruptive innovation is and what it isn’t, and to update the theory using the experience of the past two decades (source). They also described the theory as a powerful way of thinking about innovation-driven growth.
Disruptive versus sustaining innovation
The easiest way to grasp the idea is to compare two kinds of innovation. The post from Wladawsky-Berger frames the distinction like this:
- Sustaining innovations are incremental improvements to existing products and services, often made in response to the requirements of a company’s most demanding and profitable customers.
- Disruptive innovations start life as simpler, more convenient, less expensive “good enough” offerings.
- Disruptive offerings appeal to new or less-demanding customers whose needs have not been served by incumbent providers.
Those customers have often gone unserved mostly because they are not as profitable as an incumbent’s present customers. That gap is the opening an entrant can use.
How disruption plays out over time
What makes disruptive innovations dangerous to incumbents is that, if allowed to gain a market foothold, they can get on a learning curve of rapidly improving quality and capabilities while preserving the lower prices or ease of use that drove their early success. The source notes they might end up creating new markets and toppling incumbents from their leadership position (source).
Put as a sequence, a typical path looks like this:
- An entrant launches a simpler, more convenient or cheaper offering aimed at new or less-demanding customers.
- Incumbents keep improving for their most demanding and profitable customers.
- The entrant improves quickly while keeping its price or ease-of-use advantage.
- Mainstream customers start adopting the entrant’s offering in volume.
The test comes at the last step. In the revisiting paper’s words, when mainstream customers start adopting the entrants’ offerings in volume, disruption has occurred.

Why the term is so often misused
The authors of the revisiting paper warned that disruption theory was in danger of becoming a victim of its own success. Its core concepts, they wrote, have been widely misunderstood and its basic tenets frequently misapplied (source).
They add that essential refinements made over 20 years appear to have been overshadowed by the popularity of the initial formulation. As a result, the theory is sometimes criticized for shortcomings that have already been addressed.
Uber is the example used in the post to show how tricky the line can be. Everyone will agree that its growth is transforming the taxi industry around the world, but the post asks whether that counts as disruption. It also observes that it is rare for a new offering to be inherently disruptive or sustaining, because the answer often depends on the strategies of the companies involved and the dynamics of the marketplace.
A short checklist of questions follows from the definition:
- Did the offering begin as simpler, more convenient or less expensive?
- Did it first win new or less-demanding customers that incumbents were not serving?
- Are mainstream customers now adopting it in volume?
Where to go next
Disruption describes how a challenger overtakes incumbents, while the technology adoption life cycle offers a separate lens on how a new product spreads among customers over time.
If you want a process for exploring customer needs that others overlook, what is design thinking is a useful next read.
Frequently asked questions
Who introduced disruptive innovation?
Show answer
Harvard Business School professor Clayton Christensen first introduced it in a 1995 Harvard Business Review paper co-written with Joseph Bower. His 1997 book The Innovator’s Dilemma popularized it further (source).
How is disruptive innovation different from sustaining innovation?
Show answer
Sustaining innovations are incremental improvements, often aimed at a company’s most demanding and profitable customers. Disruptive innovations begin as simpler, more convenient, less expensive offerings for new or less-demanding customers.
When has disruption actually happened?
Show answer
The test is about who buys, not who launches. A newcomer that only serves a small group of new or less-demanding customers has not yet met the bar, and the label fits once the wider mainstream market moves over in volume.
Has the theory been criticized?
Show answer
Yes. A 2014 New Yorker article by Harvard history professor Jill Lepore was a rather strong critique, and the authors of the revisiting paper said the theory is sometimes criticized for shortcomings that have already been addressed (source).



